This post contains an affiliate link.
We’re going really retro here with Circle of Light 1: Greyfax Grimwald. It’s one of the books that came in my Books by the Foot sci-fi/fantasy box. I’m still editing the video for that haul and will post it as soon as possible.
Dwarf, Bear and Otter cross over Calix Stay, the river which separates the World Before Time from Atlanton Earth. Though initially unsure of the purpose of their quest, they meet some wizards and a few trustworthy humans who help keep them safe and guide them along their journey. The three unassuming friends have a pivotal role to play in the fight against the Dark Queen, who seeks to gain control over all the earth.
This book started out on shaky footing from the start, when it stated on the cover, “Beginning a great new saga for all who love THE LORD OF THE RINGS!” The author was just setting himself up for some unflattering comparisons and critiques. If the cover hadn’t mentioned The Lord of the Rings, I would have read this with a completely open mind. As it was, I was too busy trying to compare the two.
Circle of Light is not even in the same league as The Lord of the Rings, It’s like saying that Palmers and Ghiradelli chocolates taste the same. Anyone with a modicum of good taste can tell the difference. In addition to that, many elements of the story seem like a direct rip-off of The Lord of the Rings. But let’s lay those issues aside and simply talk about the merits of this story.
The plot isn’t bad. There are a few scenes which have the potential to be interesting and epic. Unfortunately, the writing is such that even major battles come across as mundane and boring. FYI–the story ends without any resolution, so you’ll have to read the next in the series to get to a satisfying stopping point.
I like the choice of animals as main characters. Bear and Otter are probably the two most endearing characters. Dwarf, the other main character, is a bit of an enigma. He seems a bit off, as if there are two warring personalities at work within him. If a character is going to exhibit behavior at both ends of the spectrum, there should be a good reason for it. Please author, what is the character’s motivation for acting the way he does?? Let me bring up another issue–character names. Holy cow, this story is chock full of names–multiple names for many characters. It got to be very confusing and didn’t add to the story at all.
Overall, I was not impressed with this book. The writing style and execution were subpar, the characters uninteresting, and the events rather boring. If you’re young and just want a so-so fantasy adventure to read, you might not mind Circle of Light. If you have a more sophisticated palate when it comes to your fantasy novels, I’d say skip it.
- Some violence
- The a-word is used a few times (as in someone is being a dunce)
Rating: 2 Stars
Until next time…